Classic Patty Melt

This classic patty melt brings together savory beef, melty cheese, and crisp buttery rye for the perfect comfort meal when you crave a diner favorite right at home. The gooey layers and tangy sauce remind me of the New York lunch counters my granddad adored.

My husband asks for these every time the weather turns cool and rainy and my kids love helping assemble the sandwiches at the skillet.

Ingredients

• Rye bread: Delivers a slightly sour note and holds up well, cook until crisp
• Softened butter: Makes for a golden brown crust, use good quality real butter
• Ground beef: Forms the heart of this melt, choose freshly ground beef with some fat content
• Ground black pepper: Adds subtle heat
• Sea salt: Brings out all the flavors
• Onion powder: Layers in a gentle sweetness and savor
• Mayonnaise: Provides the creamy base for the sauce
• Ketchup: Adds tang and a touch of sweetness
• Real bacon bits: Give a smoky salty punch, use cooked real bacon crumbled
• Sweet relish: Adds brightness and zing
• White sugar: Rounds out the sauce
• Cheddar cheese: Sharp and punchy, melts beautifully, opt for extra sharp if possible
• Provolone cheese: Gives a mellow stretch and balances flavors

Step-by-Step Instructions

Butter the Bread:

Generously spread softened butter on one side of each bread slice, cover right to the edges

Make the Patties:

In a bowl combine ground beef, ground black pepper, sea salt, and onion powder, mix until even then shape into three patties sized to fit the bread

Cook the Patties:

Preheat a nonstick skillet over medium high, add patties, cook for about three minutes then flip carefully, cook three more minutes, lower heat and finish for five more minutes until fully cooked through and browned, check with a digital thermometer for 160 degrees

Mix the Special Sauce:

While patties cook, stir together mayonnaise, ketchup, bacon bits, relish, and sugar in a small bowl, stir until completely smooth and blended, set aside

Assemble Melts:

Place one buttered bread slice butter side down in another skillet over medium low, add two slices cheddar cheese, then a cooked patty, then two slices provolone

Sauce and Top:

Spread sauce on the unbuttered side of a second bread slice, lay the sauced side down onto the provolone

Toast to Golden:

Cook each assembled sandwich for about two to three minutes on each side until the bread is crisp and golden and the cheese is soft and gooey

Finish and Serve:

Repeat with remaining ingredients for all patty melts, serve hot with extra sauce on the side

Pin it

My favorite part is sneaking a little extra sauce on my own sandwich and sneaking crumbs from the pan my dad always insisted the sauce was what truly mattered in a patty melt

Storage Tips

Wrap any leftovers tightly in foil and refrigerate for up to two days the bread will soften but reheating in a dry skillet helps restore crispness avoid microwaving if you want to keep the crust crisp

Ingredient Substitutions

Try sourdough or Texas toast if you prefer a milder bread Swiss cheese can replace provolone if that is your style or add sautéed onions to the layers for even more diner flavor

Pin it

Serving Suggestions

Pair these with classic kettle chips a simple house salad or old fashioned pickles for a true diner plate they also work great cut into halves or quarters as a party snack

Cultural Notes

The patty melt is an American diner classic first served in mid-century lunch counters it offers the best of a cheeseburger and grilled cheese in one and sparked decades of friendly debate over the best sauce

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How do you prevent the patty melt from getting soggy?

Use fully toasted rye bread and let patties rest before assembling. Spreading butter on the bread helps create a crisp barrier.

→ What cheeses melt best for a patty melt?

Cheddar and Provolone both melt smoothly and offer a rich, creamy texture. Other options include Swiss or American slices.

→ How can I ensure the beef patty cooks evenly?

Form patties that match the bread's shape and thickness. Cook over medium-high, then reduce heat to finish thoroughly.

→ Can the sauce be made in advance?

Yes, prepare the sauce a day ahead and keep refrigerated. Stir before using for even flavor distribution.

→ Is it necessary to use rye bread?

Rye bread offers classic flavor, but sourdough or whole wheat can also work if preferred.