Pin it
Stuffed baked potatoes loaded with juicy steak bites are pure comfort. Buttery beef, pillowy potato, and a rich cheesy sauce come together in every mouthful. It feels like dining out, only a whole lot easier, and your fork won't stop until the last bit's gone.
I made this by accident on a cold weekend when steak was running low and there were just a couple potatoes in the bin. When I packed the spuds full of steak smothered in that cheesy sauce, everyone wanted seconds—no leftovers here.
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Large russets: Bakes up airy with crisp jackets. Pick firm ones with no green or soft spots.
- Extra virgin olive oil: Makes those skins crispy and golden. Splash enough to coat.
- Sea salt: Makes every bite pop with flavor, especially on the outer skin.
- Steak: Try sirloin, tenderloin, ribeye, or NY strip. Use what you’ve got, just chop off any chewy edges for the best bite.
- Kosher salt: Gives steak a big flavor punch. Use a flaky one if you’ve got it.
- Fresh minced garlic: Adds tang and warmth. Chop it up right before tossing in for max flavor.
- Unsalted butter: Makes everything richer and you get to control the salt. Melts into potatoes and sauce.
- Cajun blend: Kicks up that steak’s flavor. Pick a mild one if you don’t want it too spicy, and taste before salting more.
- Avocado oil: High heat friendly, helps steak get a killer crust. Cold-pressed is best for flavor.
- Heavy cream: Brings that dreamy, velvety feel to the sauce. Fresh is best here.
- Parmesan wedge: Grate yourself for meltier, toastier flavor. It’s salty and nutty.
- Chopped parsley: Freshens up the whole dish. Use just the leaves for best flavor.
- Lemon: A little squeeze brightens everything up. Always go fresh if you can.
- Red pepper flakes: Brings gentle heat and a lovely aroma if you crush a bit first.
- Fresh ground black pepper: Gives a spice punch that’s much better than pre-ground.
Easy Step-by-Step
- Serve and Fill Potatoes:
- Start by giving your baked potatoes a little drop onto the counter to fluff 'em up. Cut a deep slit and use a fork to fluff the insides. Toss in a pat of butter if you want, add steak, and pour over that warm cheesy sauce so it drips down everywhere. Serve right away, piping hot.
- Whip Up Parmesan Sauce:
- In the same hot skillet, melt what’s left of your butter and throw in the rest of the garlic. Stir till it smells good—don’t let it brown. Slowly pour in heavy cream, scraping up any steak bits. Let it bubble gently for three to five minutes till it thickens a bit. Shake in red pepper flakes and grated parm, whisking everything till super smooth and creamy. Hit it with a squeeze of lemon and chopped parsley, salt and pepper to taste, and take it off the heat.
- Sear off Steak:
- Once potatoes start baking, cut steak into big bite pieces and trim away fat or silver skin. Toss with half your avocado oil, sprinkle lots of Cajun spice and kosher salt. Heat a cast iron skillet real hot, add leftover oil, then steak, spacing out bits. Don’t touch for about two minutes till crusty and brown. Flip once, cook a minute longer, then turn heat low for another minute to finish.
- Infuse Steak with Garlic Butter:
- Push all cooked steak to one side, toss in two spoons of butter and half your garlic on the empty side. Let it sizzle just till you smell the garlic, then roll steak bites in butter so they shine. Let them cook for one more minute, then scoop into a bowl and loosely cover with foil so they stay steamy.
- Bake Big Fluffy Potatoes:
- Set oven to 425°F and line a tray with parchment. Rub clean potatoes with oil, coat with sea salt, and set on the tray, spaced apart. Bake for fifty to sixty minutes till fork-tender. Don’t stab them before baking—this way, the insides stay super fluffy.
Pin it
Good-To-Know Stuff
- Don’t crowd the pan or steak bites steam instead of turning golden
- Everything here is naturally gluten free
- Works great to prep ahead—just put together right before serving
Can’t go wrong with steak and potatoes, but that creamy parmesan sauce is a real game changer! Every time I serve this, my kids argue over who gets the cheesiest potato—so I always make a little more sauce than needed.
Leftover Know-How
Keep stuffed potatoes in the fridge, tightly sealed, for up to two days. For best results, reheat in the oven under foil and top up with more sauce so they stay moist. Want to freeze? Just the steak and sauce, not the filled potato, for up to two months. Freezing the whole thing makes the potato texture weird.
Smart Swaps
Chicken thighs or portobello mushrooms swap in for steak if you want something different, or even a meat-free meal. Sweet potatoes totally work instead of russets for a new flavor. Heavy cream can be swapped for whole milk plus a bit more butter if you’re out. Try gruyere or asiago if parmesan’s missing from your fridge!
Pin it
How To Serve
These make an awesome main with crisp salad or roasted broccoli on the side. Make bite-sized versions using tiny potatoes and wow everyone at your next get-together. Love extra color? Just add your favorite hot sauce or a scatter of fresh herbs right on top!
Flavor Story
Steak and potatoes is an iconic combo in American homes and steakhouses—especially all over the South and Midwest. Here those old-school flavors get a fresh update with a fancy sauce and steakhouse-worthy sear right in your own kitchen.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What kind of steak works best?
Pick sirloin, ribeye, tenderloin, or NY strip for super tender bites. Use whatever you like best or what fits your wallet.
- → How do you get crispy baked potato skins?
Rub potatoes with olive oil and plenty of salt. Bake them hot so the skin turns really crunchy and tasty.
- → Can I make the parmesan cream sauce ahead of time?
Yep! Make it earlier, then just slowly heat it up before serving. Mix it well if it looks separated.
- → How do you keep steak bites juicy?
Keep the cooking quick and hot. Don't overdo it. Cover with foil after for a couple minutes to trap the juices.
- → What are good topping alternatives?
Try crispy bacon, chives, fried mushrooms, or throw on some more shredded cheese if you want more flavor or crunch.
- → Can this be made vegetarian?
Swap the steak for roasted mushrooms or a pile of sautéed veggies to keep it meatless and still filling.