Brown Sugar Pop Tart-Inspired Cookies

These indulgent brown sugar Pop Tart-inspired cookies transform a beloved breakfast pastry into an irresistible dessert experience. Each soft, chewy cookie features the warm flavors of brown sugar and cinnamon, studded with chunks of actual Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts that maintain their distinctive flakiness even after baking. Finished with a sweet glaze reminiscent of the iconic toaster pastry's frosting, these cookies deliver a perfect balance of textures and flavors in every bite – crisp edges giving way to tender centers, with pockets of Pop-Tart adding delightful surprise bursts of familiar flavor throughout.

I created these cookies after finding half a box of Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts in my pantry that had gone slightly stale – too stale for toasting but too good to waste. On a whim, I decided to chop them up and fold them into my favorite brown sugar cookie dough. The first batch disappeared within minutes of coming out of the oven, with my usually reserved husband asking when I could make them again before he'd even finished his second cookie. Even my mother-in-law, who typically declines dessert, asked for the recipe. What I love most is how the Pop-Tart pieces maintain their distinct texture and flavor, creating little pockets of nostalgia throughout each cookie.

Key Ingredients

• Brown Sugar: Creates a soft, moist texture while adding rich caramel-like flavors that perfectly complement the cinnamon. Light brown sugar works well, but dark brown sugar can be used for even deeper molasses notes.
• Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts: Provide both flavor and the distinctive flaky texture that makes these cookies unique. When baked inside the cookie, the pastry maintains its character while the filling creates pockets of intense cinnamon sweetness.
• Ground Cinnamon: Enhances the cinnamon notes already present in the Pop-Tarts, creating a cohesive flavor throughout the cookie dough. The warm, aromatic quality makes these cookies especially comforting.
• Vanilla Extract: Rounds out the flavor profile with its subtle complexity, bridging the brown sugar and cinnamon notes. Pure vanilla extract provides the cleanest flavor, though artificial works in a pinch.

Pin it

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prepare Your Workspace:

Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C) and line two baking sheets with parchment paper. Having everything ready before mixing allows you to work efficiently and prevents the dough from sitting too long once mixed.

Create the Cookie Base:

In a large mixing bowl, combine 1 cup (2 sticks) softened unsalted butter with 1 cup packed brown sugar and 1/2 cup granulated sugar. Beat with an electric mixer on medium speed for 2-3 minutes until the mixture becomes light and fluffy. This extended creaming process incorporates air into the dough, which helps create that perfect chewy texture.

Incorporate Wet Ingredients:

Add 2 large eggs one at a time, mixing well after each addition to ensure proper emulsification. Stir in 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract until fully incorporated. The eggs provide structure while adding moisture that contributes to the cookies' chewy centers.

Mix Dry Ingredients:

In a separate bowl, whisk together 2 3/4 cups all-purpose flour, 1 teaspoon baking soda, 1 1/2 teaspoons ground cinnamon, and 1/2 teaspoon salt until evenly distributed. This pre-mixing ensures the leavening agent and spices are evenly distributed throughout the dough.

Combine Wet and Dry Mixtures:

Gradually add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture, mixing on low speed just until combined. Overmixing at this stage would develop too much gluten, resulting in tough rather than tender cookies. Stop mixing as soon as no dry streaks remain.

Prepare the Pop-Tart Pieces:

Coarsely chop 6 Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts into approximately 1/2-inch pieces. The pieces should be large enough to create noticeable chunks in the cookies but small enough to distribute well throughout the dough.

Fold in the Pop-Tart Chunks:

Gently fold the chopped Pop-Tarts into the cookie dough using a spatula, not the mixer. This gentle handling preserves the texture of the Pop-Tart pieces, ensuring they remain distinct rather than getting crushed and incorporated into the dough.

Portion and Bake:

Using a 2-tablespoon cookie scoop, portion the dough onto the prepared baking sheets, spacing cookies about 2 inches apart to allow for spreading. Slightly flatten the tops of the dough balls with your fingertips to encourage even baking. Bake in the preheated oven for 10-12 minutes, or until the edges are set and just beginning to turn golden while the centers still appear slightly soft.

Perfect the Cooling Process:

Allow the cookies to cool on the baking sheets for 5 minutes before transferring to wire racks to cool completely. This brief rest on the hot baking sheet allows the cookies to firm up enough to move without breaking, while the wire racks prevent them from becoming soggy from trapped steam.

Create and Apply the Glaze:

Once the cookies are completely cool, prepare the glaze by whisking together 1 cup powdered sugar, 1-2 tablespoons milk, and 1/4 teaspoon vanilla extract until smooth. The consistency should be thick but pourable – it should drizzle from a spoon in a ribbon that holds its shape momentarily before melting back into the bowl. Using a spoon or a piping bag, drizzle the glaze over the cooled cookies in a zigzag pattern reminiscent of Pop-Tart frosting.

Mastering the Perfect Texture

Achieving the ideal cookie texture took me several attempts to perfect. My first batch spread too much during baking, resulting in thin, overly crisp cookies. I discovered that chilling the dough for just 20 minutes before portioning and baking helps control the spread while still allowing enough expansion to create that perfect chewy center and crisp edge.

The size of the Pop-Tart pieces also significantly impacts the final texture. When chopped too finely, they simply blend into the dough, losing their distinctive character. Too large, and they make the cookies difficult to portion and bite into. The sweet spot is pieces about the size of a small chocolate chip – large enough to maintain their identity but small enough to incorporate well.

Pin it

Creative Serving Ideas

These cookies are versatile enough to fit various occasions. For an indulgent dessert, I warm a cookie for 10 seconds in the microwave and serve it topped with a small scoop of vanilla ice cream, creating a delicious contrast between the warm cookie and cold ice cream. The heat slightly reactivates the Pop-Tart's flaky texture for an even more interesting eating experience.

For holiday gift-giving, I package these cookies in clear cellophane bags tied with colorful ribbons. The glaze pattern makes them look festive and professionally made, while the unique concept always sparks conversation. During fall and winter months, I sometimes add a pinch of nutmeg and clove to the dough for a more seasonal spice profile that complements the existing cinnamon beautifully.

I learned about the importance of properly incorporating the Pop-Tart pieces through a memorable kitchen mishap. During one batch, I added the Pop-Tart chunks to the mixer bowl and let the machine fold them in, which pulverized them into dust that simply blended into the dough. While the cookies still tasted good, they lost the textural contrast that makes them special. Now I always gently fold in the pieces by hand using a spatula, preserving those wonderful flaky pockets throughout the cookies.

The technique that completely transformed these cookies for me was discovering the power of properly creaming the butter and sugars. In my early batches, I rushed this step, resulting in denser cookies that lacked the perfect chewy texture. Now I set a timer for 2-3 minutes of creaming at medium speed, which incorporates just the right amount of air into the fat and sugar mixture. This creates the foundation for cookies with slightly crisp edges and tender, chewy centers – the perfect canvas for those unique Pop-Tart pieces.

Recipe Tips & Questions

→ Can I use all-purpose flour instead of cake flour?

Yes, you can substitute all-purpose flour, but the texture won't be quite as tender. For the best substitute, measure out 3 3/4 cups of all-purpose flour, remove 7 tablespoons, and replace with 7 tablespoons of cornstarch.

→ Why do my cookies spread too much when baking?

The most common reason is butter that's too warm. Make sure your butter is cool to the touch (around 60°F). Also, be sure to chill the dough as directed and use cool baking sheets (not ones that just came out of the oven).

→ Can I make smaller cookies?

Yes, you can make smaller cookies, but you'll need to adjust the amount of filling and baking time. For 2-tablespoon sized cookies, use about 1 teaspoon of filling and reduce baking time by 2-3 minutes.

→ Do I need to refrigerate these cookies?

The cookies can be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for up to 3 days. For longer storage, refrigerate for up to a week or freeze for up to 3 months.

→ Can I make these without the filling?

Yes, you can make these as regular brown sugar cinnamon cookies without the filling. Simply mix the filling spices into the cookie dough instead. The baking time will be similar, but check them a minute earlier.